Inequality, capitalism and the Nigerian elite
The distribution of income, wealth and opportunity in Nigeria, one of Africa’s well-endowed countries, mirrors Africa’s fragmented geography. Africa’s physical geography is distinctive: natural resources are unevenly distributed and most countries on the continent are landlocked. Africa has the most number of poorly endowed countries: there are more landlocked, resource-scarce countries in Africa than any other continent.
Our failure to take advantage of our natural human and natural resources and location is part of the reason why many Nigerians are poor. Our position and resources are not being harnessed: terabytes of broadband have landed on our shores yet only few universities can boast of graduates with relevant IT skills.
Knowledge and skills are not evenly spread thus limiting social mobility. The swelling population of unskilled and poorly educated youth is a major threat, politically, socially and economically.
Several of our neighbours in Central Africa could benefit from Nigeria as a hub for air freight yet we don’t have a national carrier. Meddlesome, incompetent and corrupt bureaucrats discourage private investment.
We have abundant oil resources yet we import kerosene, petrol and diesel with an astronomical increase in vessels, jetties, depots, trucks and tank farms that are clogging roads and are a threat to lives and property. Oil lifting contracts, awarded to briefcase businesspeople, are sold as a way to “encourage effective local participatio0n in the oil and gas industry” but are in fact a bonanza for cronies.
Nigeria’s demography is one of the reasons businesses – FMCGs and shopping malls – are expanding into the country. However, we cannot consume way to and what economists call convergence. Skills and knowledge boost productivity.
Poorly trained and ill-equipped young Nigerians are a tinderbox. As more and more are left behind, as they watch the gains from economic growth concentrated in hands of a few foreign trained children of wealthy Nigerians, they will question the inequality and the widening gap in opportunities.
What role can the elite of Nigeria play? Well, they must put hands and heads together, to promote policies and institutions that will begin to correct the social injustice of inequality.
Or are we waiting for a more catastrophic period in our history before we correct these wrongs? Are the well-to-do who straddle the corridors of power, who have the ears of the powers that be, going to pretend to be blind, deaf and dumb?
In a report the New Lens Scenarios, put together by strategists at Shell, perspectives on the future of business describe two scenarios. In one scenario those at the top, who occupy the commanding heights, make sure things remain as they are, that is, a “steady, self-reinforcing, lock-in of incumbent power and institutions.”
In this scenario, the rich get richer and the poor stay relatively poor. A handful of prosperous people and their children monopolise the best schools and universities. Even foundations endowed by billionaires with a conscience won’t complement the little social safety net there is. Inequality is a major issue as gaps in skills, income and wealth increase.
An alliance of businesspeople and politicians with oligarchic control won’t be easily dislodged. With pressure from civil society, a more consensual approach that accommodates varying interests through reforms is preferable alternative. This requires political will.
Rising inequality and the concentration of wealth in hands of a few rich is bad for economic growth. Though economic growth in most of Africa has made the continent the darling of the investing world as patient capital is being rewarded with huge rates of return, the growth is not inclusive. Not enough people are benefiting from it.
With its demography, strategic adoption of technology, supported with reforms in health and education, Nigeria is uniquely positioned to be Africa’s economic powerhouse. We can do away with cliquey capitalism and corruption, replacing it with entrepreneurial capitalism.